Skip to: main content or site footer.

Awards

We're incredibly proud to have received many awards over the years, for both the games we've made and for simply being the studio we are. Oh, and Tim too. He's won a few.

Because we've been making games since the year 2000, we were starting to lose track of some of the older awards. (Not bragging! The studio's just getting on there in years!) We decided to make a list, check it twice, and publish it here. Behold! All of our awards and nominations, ever. Fingers crossed we can keep adding to it over time...

65 Awards

Awards bodyCategories
Aggie Awards (8) Stacking: Best Concept (2011)
The Cave: Best Character (2013)
Broken Age: Best Music (2015)
Broken Age: Best Acting (Voice or Live Action) (2015)
Broken Age: Reader's Choice Best Setting (2015)
Broken Age: Reader's Choice Best Graphic Design (2015)
Broken Age: Reader's Choice Best Acting (Voice or Live Action) (2015)
Full Throttle Remastered: Best Re-Release, Port or Remake (2017)
Ars Technica Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)
BAFTA (3) Psychonauts: Best Screenplay (2006)
Tim Schafer: Academy Fellowship (2018)
Psychonauts 2: Performer in a Supporting Role (2022)
CNET Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)
DICE (3) Brütal Legend: Outstanding Achievement in Soundtrack (2010)
Brütal Legend: Strategy / Simulation Game of the Year (2010)
Tim Schafer: AIAS Hall of Fame (2023)
Destructoid Psychonauts 2: Xbox Game (2021)
Dr. Mark Kline Award Psychonauts 2: Mental Health Representation in Games (2022)
EGM Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)
Easy Allies Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)
Fun & Serious Festival (2) Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Best Narrative (2021)
GDC Awards (2) Double Fine Productions: Best New Studio (2006)
Psychonauts 2: Best Narrative (2021)
Game Critics Awards Psychonauts: Best of E3, Best Original Game (2002)
Game Informer (2) The Cave: Best Adventure Game (2012)
The Cave: Best Downloadable Game (2012)
Gamematters Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)
GamesIndustry.biz Double Fine Productions: Best Places to Work U.S (2022)
Gamescom Sesame Street: Once upon a Monster: Best Family Game (2011)
Godisageek Psychonauts 2: Best Story (2021)
Golden Joysticks Psychonauts 2: Xbox Game of the Year (2021)
Inverse Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)
Multiplayer.it Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)
NAVGTR (14) Psychonauts: Direction in a Game, Cinema (2005)
Psychonauts: Lead Performance in a Comedy, Richard Horvitz (2005)
Psychonauts: Supp. Performance in a Comedy, Sherrie Jackson (2005)
Psychonauts: Writing in a Comedy (2005)
Brütal Legend: Lead Performance in a Comedy, Jack Black (2009)
Brütal Legend: Writing in a Comedy (2009)
Stacking: Character Design (2011)
Broken Age: Game, Original Adventure (2014)
Broken Age: Writing in a Comedy (2014)
Psychonauts 2: Control Design 3D (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Original Light Mix Score Franchise (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Performance in a Comedy Lead (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Performance in a Comedy Supporting (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Writing in a Comedy (2021)
NME Awards (2) Double Fine Productions: Best Game Development Studio (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Best Audio In A Video Game (2022)
New York Game Awards (3) Psychonauts 2: Big Apple Award for Best Game of the Year (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Statue of Liberty Award for Best World (2022)
Tim Shafer: Legend (2022)
Spawnies (4) Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Most Emotional/Best Narrative (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Most emotional / Best Narrative (2021)
Spike Costume Quest: Best Downloadable Game (2010)
Spike Video Game Awards Brütal Legend: Best Voice, Jack Black as Eddie Riggs (2009)
TeamXbox (3) Brütal Legend: Best Story (2009)
Brütal Legend: Best Sound (2009)
Double Fine Productions: Developer of the Year (2009)
X-Play Awards Psychonauts: Best Original Game (2005)
XBox Magazine Psychonauts: Best Action/Adventure Game (2005)
XPlay Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)

102 Award Nominations

Awards bodyCategories
Aggie Awards (16) Stacking: Best Gameplay (2011)
Stacking: Best Setting (2011)
Stacking: Best Graphic Design (2011)
Stacking: Best Music (2011)
Stacking: Best Console/Handheld Adventure (Exclusive) (2011)
Stacking: Best Non-Traditional Adventure (2011)
The Cave: Best Writing – Comedy (2013)
The Cave: Best Voice Acting (2013)
Broken Age: Best Story (2015)
Broken Age: Best Writing – Comedy (2015)
Broken Age: Best Character (2015)
Broken Age: Best Concept (2015)
Broken Age: Best Setting (2015)
Broken Age: Best Graphic Design (2015)
Broken Age: Best Animation (2015)
Broken Age: Best Traditional Adventure (2015)
Annie Psychonauts: Best Animated Video Game (2006)
BAFTA (9) Brütal Legend: Best Story (2010)
Broken Age: Best Story (Act 1) (2015)
Broken Age: Best Performer (Act 2) (2016)
Psychonauts 2: Animation (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Artistic Achievement (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Game Beyond Entertainment (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Music (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Narrative (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Technical Achievement (2022)
BTVA Broken Age: Best Male Lead Vocal Performance, Elijah Wood (2015)
Carmen Electra Game Awards Psychonauts: Best Original Game (2005)
DICE (10) Psychonauts: Outstanding Achievement in Game Design (2006)
Brütal Legend: Outstanding Achievement in Character Performance (2010)
Brütal Legend: Outstanding Achievement in Original Story (2010)
Brütal Legend: Outstanding Achievement in Game Direction (2010)
Iron Brigade: Strategy/Simulation Game of the Year (2012)
MASSIVE CHALICE: Outstanding Achievement in Game Design (2016)
Psychonauts in the Rhombus of Ruin: Immersive Reality Game of the Year (2018)
Psychonauts 2: Outstanding Achievement in Music Composition (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Outstanding Achievement in Story (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Adventure Game of the Year (2022)
Dragon Slayer Awards MASSIVE CHALICE: Notable Kickstarter of The Year (2013)
Easy Allies (2) Psychonauts 2: Best World (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Best Narrative (2021)
GANG (4) Psychonauts 2: Best Original Soundtrack Album (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Music Of The Year (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Best Voice Performance (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Dialog of the Year (2022)
GDC Awards (2) Psychonauts 2: Best Design (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Best Visual Art (2021)
Gamemusic Psychonauts 2: Best Soundtrack (2021)
Gayming (2) Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2022)
Psychonauts 2: Best LGBTQ Character Award, Helmut Fullbear & Bob Zanotto (2022)
Golden Joystick Awards Broken Age: Best Original Game (2014)
IGN Psychonauts in the Rhombus of Ruin: Best VR Experience (2017)
NAVGTR (32) Psychonauts: Game of the Year (2005)
Psychonauts: Animation in a Game, Cinema (2005)
Psychonauts: Art Direction in a Game, Cinema (2005)
Psychonauts: Art Direction in a Game, Engine (2005)
Psychonauts: Character Design (2005)
Psychonauts: Original Action Game (2005)
Brütal Legend: Art Direction (2009)
Brütal Legend: Character Design (2009)
Brütal Legend: Costume Design (2009)
Brütal Legend: Direction in a Game Cinema (2009)
Brütal Legend: Supp. Performance in a Comedy, Tim Curry (2009)
Brütal Legend: Song Collection (2009)
Brütal Legend: Game Original Action (2009)
Costume Quest: Writing in a Comedy, Costume Quest (2010)
Costume Quest: Original Children’s Game (2010)
Iron Brigade: Strategy Game (2011)
Sesame Street: Once upon a Monster: Original Children’s Game (2011)
Sesame Street: Once upon a Monster: Writing in a Comedy (2011)
Stacking: Original Adventure Game (2011)
Stacking: Writing in a Comedy (2011)
Happy Action Theater: Original Family Game (2012)
The Cave: Game Design, New IP (2013)
Broken Age: Lead Performance in a Comedy, Elijah Wood (2014)
Broken Age: Supporting Performance in a Comedy, David Kaufman (2014)
Grim Fandango Remastered: Classic Revival Game (2015)
Day of the Tentacle Remastered: Classic Revival Game (2016)
Day of the Tentacle Remastered: Writing in a Comedy (2016)
Headlander: Control Design, 2D or Limited 3D (2016)
Headlander: Writing in a Comedy (2016)
Psychonauts 2: Character Design (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Gameplay Design Franchise (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Song Original or Adapted (2021)
NYVGCC Middle Manager of Justice: The A Train Award for Best Mobile/iOS Game (2013)
New York Game Awards Psychonauts 2: Best Writing (2022)
SXSW Psychonauts 2: Video Game of the Year (2022)
Satellite Awards Psychonauts: Best Action/Adventure Game (2005)
Saturn Psychonauts: Best Video Game Release (2006)
Spawnies (4) Psychonauts 2: Diversity (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Best Adventure (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Diversity Award (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Best Adventure Game (2021)
Spike Video Game Awards (3) Brütal Legend: Best Action Adventure Game (2009)
Brütal Legend: Best Soundtrack (2009)
Brütal Legend: Best Cast (2009)
Steam Awards Psychonauts 2: Outstanding visual Style (2021)
The Game Awards (5) Broken Age: Best Independent Game (2014)
Psychonauts 2: Game of the Year (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Narrative (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Art Direction (2021)
Psychonauts 2: Best Action/Adventure Game (2021)

Skip up to: site menu or main content